Angela Breitenbach (Cambridge) / Lucy Allais (University of Witwatersrand/Johns Hopkins)
The 2026 Joint Session of the Aristotelian Society and the Mind Association
The University of Reading, 8th to 10th July 2026.
Symposium I -Kantian Climate Justice
Angela Breitenbach
Cambridge
Lucy Allais
University of Witwatersrand/Johns Hopkins
Abstracts
Coming soon.
Kant’s political philosophy might seem an unlikely resource for theorizing our rights and obligations in relation to climate injustice. A political philosophy based on defending individual freedom rather than promoting welfare or some other conception of the good, that opens with private property and private contract, and that seems to treat the world and its resources as fundamentally available to be made into private parcels, subject to private control in the pursuit of private purposes, might be thought to be the source of the problem. Angela Breitenbach argues that Kant’s practical philosophy is less individualist than it is often taken to be, and includes resources for thinking about our individual obligations with respect to the climate emergency. My response takes up Breitenbach’s idea that Kant takes our ethical obligations to be indeterminate without the right political institutions. I take this to get at something crucial for understanding Kant’s complete position as well as important for thinking about the climate emergency. I argue that on Kant’s systemic approach to individual freedom, it is confused to view private property, markets and market actors such as business corporations, as providing starting limits, ‘interference’ in which is in tension with individual freedom. On the contrary, the structure of his position makes climate justice a necessary background condition of individual freedom.
About
Coming soon.
Lucy Allais is jointly appointed at the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, and Johns Hopkins University. She got her D.Phil. from Oxford, had her first job at Sussex University, and has also worked at the University of California, San Diego. She has published extensively on Kant’s first Critique, primarily on his transcendental idealism and issues to do with the nature of intuition in his account. More recently she has been working on his political philosophy, including thinking about the nature of markets and common resources. She also has interests in moral emotions, in particular, forgiveness. She is currently working on human free agency.