The Aristotelian Society

The Aristotelian Society

est. 1880

Symposium VI

Relativism

Chaired by Wendy Parker (Durham)

Maria Baghramian  | 2019 Joint Session of the Aristotelian Society and the Mind Association | Durham University

The Virtues of Relativism

Maria Baghramian (UC Dublin)

Abstract

What is it about relativism that justifies or at least explains its continued appeal in the face of relentless attacks through the history of philosophy? This paper explores a new answer to this old question, casting the response in metaphilosophical terms. Section I introduces the problem. Section II argues that one part of the answer is that some of the well-known defences of relativism take it to be a  philosophical stance - that is, a broad perspective or orientation with normative consequences -  rather than a doctrine or a thesis. Section III draws attention to an assumption, not always explicitly stated by its proponents, that the relativist stance leads to the cultivation of some key intellectual virtues. Open-mindedness, tolerance, intellectual humility, and curiosity are examples of the intellectual virtues that relativism can foster. Section IV argues that the defence of relativism on the basis of the virtues that are assumed to follow from it,  at best, is only partially successful.  Moreover, there is a range of epistemic vices, resulting from the stance, that undercuts the virtue-based defence presented in section III.  

Biography

Maria Baghramian is Full  Professor of American Philosophy, the Head of the School of Philosophy and co-director of the UCD Cognitive Science Programme at University College Dublin, Ireland.  She was elected Member of the Royal Irish Academy in 2010 and  was a Fulbright Senior Scholar in Harvard in 2014.  In 2011 she founded the Society for Women in Philosophy- Ireland (SWIP-I) and was the Chair until 2018. Her research and publications have focused onrelativism, pluralism, and Neo-pragmatist American philosophy. Her most recent book is The Problem of Relativism, co-authored with Annalisa Coliva (Routledge 2019). Currently she is a Principal Investigator, with Prof. Luke Drury,  of “When Experts Disagree” (WEXD), an interdisciplinary research project on trust and expertise, funded by the Irish Research Council, and a member of the British Academy/ALLEA working group on “Truth, Trust and Expertise”. Among the publications of these projects is her edited book From Trust to Trustworthiness (Routledge 2019). Baghramian was born in Iran in an Armenian family but moved to Ireland in 1979. 

Martin Kusch | 2019 Joint Session of the Aristotelian Society and the Mind Association | Durham University

Relativist Stances, Virtues and Vices

Martin Kusch (Vienna)

Abstract

This paper comments on Maria Baghramian’s ‘The Virtues of Relativism’. We agree that some relativist positions are naturally couched as ‘stances’ and that it is fruitful to connect relativism to virtue epistemology. But I find Baghramian’s preferred rendering of relativism uncharitable.

Biography

Martin Kusch is professor for philosophy of science and epistemology at the University of Vienna. From 2014 until May 2019 we was PI of an ERC Advanced Grant Project entitled “The Emergence of Relativism: Historical, Philosophical and Sociological Issues”. Prior to moving to Vienna in 2009, he was a Reader in the Science Studies Unit in Edinburgh (1993-1997) and Professor for Philosophy and Sociology of Science at the Department for History and Philosophy of Science in Cambridge (1997-2009). He has published widely in epistemology, philosophy of science, philosophy of language and social studies of science. He is currently writing a book on relativism in the philosophy of science, and editing the Routledge Handbook on Relativism. Main past book publications are: Language as Calculus versus Language as a Universal Medium (Reidel 1989), Foucault’s Strata and Fields (Reidel 1991), Psychologism (Routledge 1995), Psychological Knowledge (Routledge 1998), (with H.M. Collins) The Shape of Actions (MIT 1999), Knowledge by Agreement (OUP 2002), and A Sceptical Guide to Meaning and Rules (Acumen 2006).


further info

future joint sessions

XCIV
2020 joint session:
Kent

july 2020

XCV
2021 joint session:
Hertfordshire

july 2021

XCVI
2022 joint session:
TBC

july 2022





supplementary volume




The inaugural address and symposia for the Joint Session are published in the Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume, which is published digitally and in hardcover every June. The Supplementary Volume is sent to subscribing members of the Society in categories 4 and 5.

Members in other categories can purchase the hardcover Supplementary Volume from the Online Shop. Volumes will also be available at the registration desk during the conference.

Subscriptions to the Supplementary Volume also includes online access via Wiley Online Library (please note that one-off purchases of the hardcover volume do not include membership or online access).

The 2018 Joint Session of the Aristotelian Society and the Mind Association | Cardiff University

past conferences

XCII
2018 joint session:
Oxford

6 - 8 july 2018

XCI
2017 joint session:
Edinburgh

14 - 16 july 2017

XC
2016 joint session:
cardiff

8 - 10 july 2016





subscribing memberships

Subscribing members receive online access to the Proceedings from 2000 to the most current issue.

Subscribing members also receive the bound, hardcover volume of the latest Proceedings through the post.

overview